Keil Logo Arm Logo

News News Item

13 Mar 2017

CMSIS-RTOS Choices: Keil RTX or FreeRTOS

ARM extends CMSIS compliant real-time operating systems for the microcontroller industry with CMSIS-RTOS v2 and the adoption of Keil RTX and FreeRTOS.

CMSIS-RTOS is a generic RTOS interface for ARM® Cortex®-M processor-based devices. It provides a standardized API for software components that require RTOS functionality and gives therefore serious benefits to the users and the software industry:

  • CMSIS-RTOS provides basic features that is required in many embedded applications.
  • The unified feature set of the CMSIS-RTOS reduces learning efforts and simplifies sharing of software components.
  • Middleware components that use the CMSIS-RTOS interface are easier to adapt.

The CMSIS-RTOS v2 API extends the first implementation and addresses the following new requirements:

  • Dynamic object creation no longer requires static memory, static memory buffers are now optional.
  • Support for TrustZone technology on Cortex-M provides a secure and non-secure execution area.
  • Provisions for message passing in multi-core systems and C++ run-time environments.
  • C interface which is binary compatible across ABI compatible compilers.

RTOS choices with compatible API

A lock-in into a specific RTOS kernel introduces some project risk as requirements may change over the project life-cycle, for example, when deterministic interrupt response or support for a new processor core is required. ARM offers therefore various implementations of the CMSIS-RTOS as shown in the following picture.

RTOS Choices with compatible API

When using the CMSIS-RTOS API, the underlying RTOS kernel can be easily replaced. Also migration of CMSIS-RTOS v1 to CMSIS-RTOS v2 is simplified with the compatibility layer.

  • Keil RTX4 is available since 2005 and the basis for the original CMSIS-RTOS v1 reference implementation. It is also part of the current mbed OS scheduler.
  • Keil RTX5 is a new ground-up implementation that natively supports the CMSIS-RTOS v2 API. The kernel supports all Cortex-M processors (including Cortex-M23/M33) and the compatibility layer provides CMSIS-RTOS v1 compliance. RTX5 uses Cortex-M hardware features and never disables interrupts during kernel execution (except for Cortex-M0/M0+).
  • FreeRTOS is widely adopted to different processors and is now available with a CMSIS-RTOS v2 API interface. CMSIS-RTOS v1 based applications may use the compatibility layer.

Select RTOS in MDK

All CMSIS-RTOS implementations are provided as Software Pack that simplifies project integration. Keil RTX4 and RTX5 are part of the CMSIS Software Pack. The FreeRTOS implementation is a separate software pack available from www.keil.com/pack, the Pack Installer, or GitHub. The picture below shows the selection of FreeRTOS with the CMSIS-RTOS compliant API or the a native FreeRTOS API. When using the CMSIS-RTOS2 configuration file, the native FreeRTOS API is still available which allows project migration over time.

MDK Run-Time Environment - FreeRTOS selection

RTOS Kernel Awareness and Event Recorder

The CMSIS-RTOS implementations are supported in the uVision Debugger with the Component Viewer for kernel awareness and the Event Recorder for analysing the dynamic run-time behaviour. The picture below shows FreeRTOS debugging using the MDK-Lite edition and the uVision Debugger in simulation mode - no target hardware is required.

Event Recorder for FreeRTOS

Getting started with CMSIS-RTOS

Keil logo

Arm logo
Important information

This site uses cookies to store information on your computer. By continuing to use our site, you consent to our cookies.

Change Settings

Privacy Policy Update

ARM’s Privacy Policy has been updated. By continuing to use our site, you consent to ARM’s Privacy Policy. Please review our Privacy Policy to learn more about our collection, use and transfers
of your data.